In the early days of Cat & the Fiddle, our team faced numerous challenges and joys as we embarked on our cheesecake journey. Cat & the Fiddle started as a small kitchen, offering a humble yet delightful selection of just 10 flavors, each crafted with love and care. Our customers adored these flavors and frequently expressed a desire to try them all. This recurring request sparked an idea among our team—why not create a cake that allowed customers to enjoy every flavor in a single purchase?

The idea was as daring as it was exciting, and we knew it had the potential to create something extraordinary. With creativity and determination, we began experimenting. Instead of blending the flavors into a singular taste, we decided to cut a slice from each of our 10 flavors and combine them into a makeshift cake. After countless trials, we perfected the masterpiece that would become known as the "Fickle Feline." This cheesecake, a symphony of individual slices, became a testament to our commitment to innovation and our desire to delight our customers.

We then started our small-scale operation. It was an ambitious and optimistic idea to produce 100 Fickle Feline every Wednesday as a limited item, whenever our production schedule allowed it! The Fickle Feline quickly captured hearts, becoming a symbol of our journey and a favorite among cheesecake enthusiasts.

Each slice offers a delightful surprise, a perfect medley of flavors that transports you back to the early days of Cat & the Fiddle, where passion and creativity overcame challenges, and a simple idea led to the birth of a legendary cake. It became such a hit with our customers that we made it a permanent offering! To this day, it remains one of our best-selling flavors!